Purpose: A better understanding of applicant attraction enables organizations to manage their talent needs, thus enhancing HR effectiveness. Even though generational difference exists in modern organizations, scholarly work investigating the salient predictors of applicant attraction between the Gen-X and millennial cohorts is missing. We attempt to inform the literature by addressing this gap. Design/methodology/approach: The study captures applicant attraction using a survey-based study of 1949 working employees in India, representing Gen-X and millennial generations. Findings: The study provides critical factors that differentially impact millennial and Gen-X members’ attraction towards an organization. It also reveals that satisfaction in the current job affects millennials and the Gen-X cohorts differently. Research limitations/implications: Recruitment research has neglected the predictors of applicant attraction among generational cohorts. Further, studies on generational differences have originated in western contexts and have ignored the emerging economies. Based on the responses of working professionals, our study increases the generalizability of the results. Implications: The multi-generational workplace has the largest proportion of both Gen-X and millennial employees. A deeper understanding of their preferences can help HR practitioners leverage the drivers of applicant attraction. Our study provides inputs to design recruitment strategies to target generational groups within and outside the organization. Originality/value: The present study examines the phenomenon in an emerging market marked by a high economic growth rate and an eastern cultural context. Our study presents a more realistic representation of applicant needs by sourcing inputs from working employees across generation groups.